Skip to Content

Chicken & Mozzarella Stuffed Baby Peppers with Balsamic Glaze

This recipe for Chicken & Mozzarella Stuffed Baby Peppers with Balsamic Glaze was inspired by a few things. One was the bags of tiny adorable peppers at Aldi’s.

Chicken & Mozzarella Stuffed Baby Peppers with Balsamic Glaze

The other was my really private boyfriend who doesn’t like to be mentioned 😉 He’s on a health kick and one of his better ideas was using peppers instead of bread for sandwiches. All his other ideas involve mushrooms and are therefor terrible.

Luckily I was in the mood for another appetizer recipe because the small peppers had bite-sized snack written all over them.

I’m planning on a dinner sized variation on this recipe but it’s going to wait until peppers are more reasonable this summer. For the time being we have little baby peppers.

I experimented quite a bit with these guys. Unfortunately the end product wasn’t as pretty as I wanted but they did taste really good!

red, orange and yellow pepper filled with chicken and melted mozzarella cheese

The mini peppers from Aldi’s come in a mixed bag of red, orange and yellow. They make a pretty festive display cooked up together.

Use a sharp knife to cut the peppers in half through the stem. Scoop out the seeds with a spoon.

broiled red, orange and yellow peppers

Try to cut the peppers so they’ll lay flat without too much wobble. I broiled them twice, first cut side down. I used my cast iron griddle for this.

For the filling I used baked chicken thighs. I always buy thighs because they’re cheap, really nothing more to it than that.

My go-to baked chicken method is to toss my cast iron skillet in the oven while it preheats. Carefully pull it out and add the chicken with a little salt and pepper.

Bake at 400 until I remember to take it out of the oven. Usually by the time I smell the roasted chicken in my living room it’s done

I chopped up the filling in my food processor. Add the chicken, the mozzarella and some black pepper and chop it up.

red, orange and yellow pepper filled with chicken and melted mozzarella cheese

After the first trip under the broiler I flipped the peppers over and added the chopped filling. Back under the broiler they went. Isn’t that the best oven mitt? Sooo many bear hands jokes in my kitchen!

The sauce for the cheesy chicken pepper bites couldn’t be easier. Heat balsamic vinegar over low-med until it’s reduced to a syrupy consistency.

It will thicken up a little more in the fridge so keep that in mind if you plan to make it ahead of time.

Don’t forget to PIN this to your Appetizer or Recipe board for later!

Yield: 4

Chicken & Mozzarella Stuffed Baby Peppers with Balsamic Glaze with a Balsamic Glaze

red, orange and yellow pepper filled with chicken and melted mozzarella cheese

Turn a bag of adorable mini peppers into a delicious appetizer with this recipe for Cheesy Chicken Stuffed Pepper Bites with a Balsamic Glaze. They cook quickly under the broiler so you can get back to having fun asap

Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 25 minutes


  • 12-18 Baby Peppers
  • 1 Cup Baked Chicken
  • 1 Cup Fresh Mozzarella
  • Pepper, to taste
  • 1/3 Cup Balsamic Vinegar


  1. Heat balsamic vinegar in a small saucepan over low-medium heat until reduced to a syrupy consistency
  2. Combine chicken and mozzarella to the bowl of the food processor, season with pepper and chop. Don't leave any large chunks but you don't want a paste either
  3. Turn the broiler on high
  4. Slice the peppers in half through the stems. Use a spoon to scoop out the seeds
  5. Place cut side down on a small pan and place under the broiler for about 2 minutes until the skins begin to blister
  6. Carefully flip the peppers and use a spoon to add some filling to each
  7. Place back under the broiler until the cheese is melted and starting to brown
  8. Remove from the oven and drizzle with balsamic reduction

Check out my Recipe Page for more ideas or start with these:

jalapenos, cream cheese and bacon rolled up in crescent dough


taco dip on a frito, taco dip in a white bowl on a stone tile with fritos

What to Expect from Farm Fresh Eggs
← Previous
How to Identify Chick Breeds
Next →
Skip to Recipe