click map Twitter Instagram Pinterest Facebook

Halloween Witch Hat Cookies


I’m off my game (again!) I’m always ready for Halloween in August and then I blink and it’s October 20th. My kid doesn’t even have a costume! For the record she’s going to be a bat and the fabric is somewhere on my kitchen table. I was feeling like a Halloween failure so I put on Hocus Pocus and got to baking. You’ve probably made a version of these cookies, I’ve seen them called peanut butter blossoms but growing up we called them the kiss cookies.

Fancy up simple Hershey Kiss cookies to make adorably sweet Witch Hats perfect to help your little monsters celebrate HalloweenThis chocolate hazelnut twist on the classic is perfect on it’s own but with a little pizzaz they become fancy witch hat cookies. I’ve given you two options for decorations but two other options in case you’re not a fan of candy melts are a ring of colored icing or candy laces held in place by a dab of icing. If you take either of those routes wait a few hours until the cookies are completely cool and the kisses have reset (they get very soft and if you accidentally smack them with the next layer of your 3-Tier Cooling Rackyou might want to cry a little)

Fancy up simple Hershey Kiss cookies to make adorably sweet Witch Hats perfect to help your little monsters celebrate Halloween

5.0 from 1 reviews
Witch Hat Halloween Cookies
Recipe type: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 30-35 cookies
Fancy up simple Hershey Kiss cookies to make adorably sweet Witch Hats perfect to help your little monsters celebrate Halloween
  • 35-45 Unwrapped Dark Chocolate Hershey Kisses
  • ½ c Orange Candy Melts
  • Orange Sanding Sugar
  • ½ c Butter, softened
  • ½ C White Sugar
  • ½ C Brown Sugar
  • ½ C Nutella
  • 1 Egg
  • 1¼ C Flour
  • ¼ C Cocoa Powder
  • ¾ t Baking Soda
  • ½ t Baking Powderx
  • Mini M&Ms
  1. Preheat oven to 375F, if your butter is in the fridge (because you cats and/or dog enjoy stealing and consuming the entire stick...) this is a good time to stick it in the mixer bowl to soften
  2. Heat the candy melts in a shallow cup (glass ramekins are great for this) for 30 seconds, stir and heat for 15 second intervals until completely melted
  3. Place a sheet of parchment or waxed paper on the counter. Dip the bottom on a kiss in the candy and then immediately into the colored sugar, do this for half of the kisses. You have to move fast or the heat from your hands will melt the candy
  4. Dip the other half in the candy melts but skip the sanding sugar. Set the kisses aside until the cookies come out of the oven
  5. Add the white and brown sugar, the Nutella and the egg to the butter in thebowl of the mixer. Mix on med-low until well blended
  6. Add in flour, cocoa powder, baking powder and baking soda and mix until dough forms. It will seem really dry and unlikely to come together but it will!
  7. Place one inch balls 2 inches apart on ungreased cookie sheets.
  8. Bake for 8-10 minutes
  9. Immediately add the kisses, transfer cookies to cooking rack
  10. Add a mini M&M to the 'hat band' on the cookies without sanding sugar


  1. Love these! They are so adorable and perfect for this time of year.
    becky recently posted…My Favorite PartMy Profile

  2. Lisa Nolan says:

    Who doesn’t love Halloween cookies! These are almost too cute to eat (almost)! Pinned!

  3. These are adorable treats perfect for any Halloween party! I am looking for class party ideas so this is great timing!
    Ashley @irishred02 recently posted…New Trailer and Images from Star Wars The Force Awakens!My Profile

  4. These cookies are so cute! My kids were just planning our halloween menu, I’ can’t wait to show them this idea!
    Amanda recently posted…Ad: Easy Movie Night Dinner with Homemade Honey Mustard DipMy Profile

  5. Adorable! I love the orange sprinkles around the bottom of the hat.
    They look super easy and quick to make too.
    Can’t wait to try these with my kids tonight.

  6. These are so cute and super simple!!

  7. These little witch hat cookies are too cute! Gotta get my Winnie from Hocus Pocus fix soon and whip some of these up. 🙂
    Christina recently posted…How To Organize Your ClosetMy Profile

  8. Nice! I have a party tomorrow- I should try to make these!
    Milena recently posted…Eggtastic Microwave Egg Cooker #SeenOnTV #Food #ReviewMy Profile

  9. Oh my gosh, these are super cute and sound simple to make! I’ll have to whip up a batch of these for the kids to enjoy after trick-or-treating. It’s a tradition for us to bake and eat cookies instead of candy on Halloween. =)
    Trisha recently posted…Comment on Sticking to our budget with American Express Serve Cash Back! #ServeSomeGood #IC by ChristinaMy Profile